Friday, 4 December 2015

Bombing Syria: Just how evil are politicians?

On Wednesday, the House of Commons voted for War. Or maybe it was for Peace in Syria. They voted to kill innocent civilians. Or maybe it was to protect them. They voted to attack yet Muslim country. Or maybe they voted to defend our own people.

Whether it was Corbyn’s “Terrorist sympathisers” or Cameron’s “Western warmongers”, inside the House and out of it, oversimplifications have been in abundance these last few days. While I’m not in favour of the strikes, I’ve been annoyed by so many black-and-white characterisations of last night’s vote. Many, including Corbyn himself, have given passionate and principled arguments against the strikes.  Crucially, they respected their colleagues’ different opinions. Rather than demonising those who disagreed with them, they recognised the equally strong moral conviction of their opponents. 

But not everyone been so nuanced in their understanding. I find it unbelievable that so many people have dismissed supporters of the strike as immoral warmongers. Do they honestly believe that MPs walked through the voting lobby thinking gleefully about killing Syrian children? How can they think that anyone could take that decision lightly? Just think of those MPs that decided to vote for the strike. As a Labour leadership candidate, Yvette Cooper put her head above the parapet by calling for the UK to accept 10,000 refugees. Lib-Dems like Tim Farron took a strong moral stand against the Iraq War but voted in favour of strikes. As Secretary for International Development, Hillary Benn dramatically increased spending on foreign aid.*  

Can we really say any of these people are no more than heartless warmongers? Are they any less sincere? Are they any less moral?

Pacifists believe that only non-violence can bring about a more peaceful world. Fair enough. But we have to remember that it is not only pacifists who want peace in Syria and Iraq. Those who voted for the strikes did so because they sincerely believe that limited military action, although undesirable, would be the most effective way of defeating ISIS and bring about peace in the long run. Of course we may well disagree with that. But we have to remember that people with the same aims can come to different conclusions. It is incredibly arrogant to suggest that your own conclusion is the only moral conclusion.

Again, I know this doesn’t represent the opinions of all pacifists, let alone those non-pacifists who opposed the strikes. But if we really want a “kinder and gentler politics”, we can start by avoiding inaccurate and offensive characterisations of our opponents.

So let’s be clear about a few things. For a start, politicians didn’t vote for “War.” They didn’t need to do that. There already was a war. And that war would have carried on regardless of how MPs voted. In fact, MPs were deciding how to bring about an end to that war. Many of them decided that extending targeted military strikes could do that.  Of course, others weren’t convinced. But it was clear from the many passionate speeches of MPs on both sides of the debate wanted the same thing- peace.



Neither did they choose War over Peace. As was clear from speeches on both sides of the debate, everyone wanted a “comprehensive political settlement” to the crisis in Syria. But even with a comprehensive peace agreement, the question over what to do with ISIS would remain. ISIS will not negotiate. Moreover, we (rightly) wouldn’t let them. A peace agreement that didn’t take into account ISIS would just let them conquer the rest of Syria more easily. Pro-strike MPs want a political settlement, but they believe there are limits to that settlement. That is not the same as trying to “bomb their way” out of a crisis.

They didn’t vote to kill innocent civilians. I find it hard to believe how many people have accused them of doing just that. They voted for targeted strikes against ISIS. Yes, that may result in civilian deaths. But those deaths would be not be intentional. Of course, civilian casualties are tragedies regardless of whether they are targeted deliberately or not. However, morally, voting for targeted airstrikes that may unintentionally kill civilians is different to deliberately targeting civilians. That’s not what the vote was about. Do we honestly think that those who voted in favour the strikes sought to emulate Bashar al-Assad’s shelling of civilians in Homs? Do we think they have ceased to care about Syrian refugees because they voted to carry out targeted attacks?

No.  They made the judgement that the strikes would save far more civilians than they would kill. We may disagree with that judgement. But the fact remains that they took that decision with the aim of saving civilian lives. They aren’t evil for thinking that. We need to draw a distinction between our local MP and the likes of Bashar al-Assad.
Of course there were plenty of perfectly good reasons for opposing the strikes. Personally, I felt that those in favour of the strikes made a strong moral argument without making a strong military case for action. It was assumed that ISIS could be defeated just by increasing the number of airstrikes. However, experts from King’s College London’s Department of War Studies questioned Cameron’s strategy. A former senior CIA official even questioned whether the strikes would really be help to make Britain more secure.**

But we have to recognise that MPs on both sides of the debate were motivated by the same desire to protect the people of Syria and the UK.

Those of us who think the strikes will make things worse should be humble. We have to remember that many others want the best for Syria. More than that, maybe we should hope that our fears will be proven to be unjustified. Maybe, for once, we should hope that we are wrong.

* Many on the left have criticised Benn for passionately arguing for something his father, “the real Benn”, would have passionately opposed. But anyone who reads anything by Tony Benn, a politician who was the paragon of decency, will quickly realise that he loved his son and respected his convictions. He would be deeply upset by the way those on the left have talked about him


**I was going to talk more about what I didn’t think more strikes were a good idea, but I’ve spoken far too much already. (As always.) Just watch Richard Burgen MP’s 4 minute speech here and you’ll know what I think: 

Saturday, 14 November 2015

Responding to Tragedy: Are We Just Biased to the West?



As France enters three days of national mourning, it seems as if so much of the world has joined them in solidarity. While everyone agrees that the Paris were tragedies acts that deserve our righteous anger and grief, some have questioned why we haven’t responded to Thursday’s attacks in Beirut with the outpouring of sympathy. With ISIS claiming responsibility for both, it’s an understandable question. But I’m sceptical of those just blaming racism or a  conscious bias to the West. I think our response is more nuanced and more morally justifiable than that.

Is the media just biased to the problems of the West? Most likely, there’s some truth in that, but I think the issue is more complicated that it’s made out to be.  The reality is, that the attacks in Beirut were just a small part of the many acts of violence happening across the world this week. On Friday, a suicide bombing claimed 19 lives in Baghdad. Syria’s bloody civil war continues. Burundi, according to the UN, seems to be on the verge of perpetrating acts of genocide. The list goes on. Even if the news had focused on Beirut and Paris in equal measures, it would still have failed to cover most other acts of mass murder. If the news reported every single atrocity in the world, then bulletins would be no more than a list of tragedies. They wouldn’t have time to explore the suffering caused by each one.  Where would be the dignity in that?  News outlets have to prioritise however much they try to report with balance and fairness. So they will choose to report the extraordinary. It’s far from perfect. Undoubtedly, subconscious biases and the pursuit of profit will play a part. It’s difficult to see a way around. At least the internet gives us access to alternative sources of information that can help counteract those biases.

But what about our emotional responses to attacks like this? Do we just care more about people “like us” who die? Again, I think it’s more complicated than that. If it’s difficult for the media to report every atrocity going the world, it’s even more impossible for us to emotionally engage with every tragedy that happens each day. They call it compassion fatigue. We see so many images of victims that we become numb to their suffering. At best, we muster a reverent but short-lived sympathy when we see reports of horrors that we are powerless to change. We know that’s not right. But it’s simply impossible to live our lives constantly empathising with those who are suffering in this world.
However, because we know that we can’t respond appropriately to every horror we see each day, rather than do nothing, we decide to engage fully with a small part of the suffering we see in the world.  There are many factors which affect what we choose to respond to, but two in particular stand out for me. Firstly, we respond when we think our response can change something. Secondly, we respond when the suffering is closest to us. I think our reaction to the refugee crisis illustrates this perfectly. We all know about the terrible ongoing civil war in Syria. We all vaguely know about the lives of people under oppressive regimes like Iran and Saudi Arabia. And we all have an idea about the desperate poverty of so many people in developing nations. But the suffering was so immense and so far away that we felt powerless to change anything. However, when we saw those same people drowning in the Mediterranean Sea, that suffering was suddenly in our backyard. More than that, it seemed like it was preventable. And so, suddenly, there was a public emotional engagement with the issue.  We donated, we volunteered and collectively our anger and sadness pressured European leaders into acting. The crisis isn’t solved, but we can be sure that our emotional engagement mattered. Did we think of any refugee as a lesser human being before they decided to cross the Mediterranean Sea? No, but we felt that our emotional engagement could do little to stop their suffering. But when their suffering was both preventable and in our backyard, we decided to care.

So how does this relate to Paris? We know that terrorism is evil. We want to respond to that. But In a world of twenty-four hour news, when atrocities are so frequently reported, we are numb to the full extent of the suffering terrorism causes. We find it particularly hard to feel the effects of terrorism when we are so far away. That’s the case with the attacks in Beirut and Baghdad. We know it’s awful, but we just can’t relate to the extent of the suffering terrorism causes.

But it’s different when it happens in Paris. It’s in our backyard. Like many of my fellow students in Paris, so many people have messaged me to check if I’m safe. Many of us will know someone in Paris, but not so many of us will know someone in Beirut.  So the attacks feel more real because the possibility of losing somebody is much higher. Even if we don’t know anyone in Paris, most of us have been there. As a result, it feels more real to us. More than that, we know that the victims were leading similar lives to us. They were killed in the type of places that we visit. So we see more clearly how our lives can be suddenly and tragically cuts short. That may not be the case when attacks happen with very different cultures. When attacks happen in places that are geographically or culturally close to us, they feel more real to us. So it’s easier for us to engage emotionally with it.

It’s the same when we a friend loses someone close to them. Even if we’ve never met the person they’ve lost, we can share in their grief and try to comfort them. Why? Because we see the effects of that loss on someone we love, and so are better able to understanding what they’re going through. A stranger’s bereavement may be just as devastating for them, but however hard we try, we can’t feel it in the same way.


So we need to be careful before we devalue someone’s sympathy by saying that it’s biased to “people like them”. We can’t respond to everything, and so when we do respond to something, it may well be because we have something in common with the person who’s suffering. Maybe that’s the way we deal with the scale of human suffering around us. Maybe that’s just our imperfect response to an imperfect world. 

Wednesday, 7 October 2015

Spitting lefties?

“Don’t believe everything you read in the paper”

I’m usually skeptical. Not skeptical of the press, but skeptical of those who are skeptical. I don’t want to believe that everyone is lying to me. And I find it curious that I’m only implored to be skeptical whenever I suggest an alternative point of view.

However, this week’s coverage of the Conservative conference made me think of my own experiences of protesting and the way in which coverage can be distorted. Every newspaper was keen to point out that the spitting, the verbal abuse and the egg-throwing were only the actions of a small minority. The organisers of the protest rightfully condemned this behaviour. Without a doubt, it was awful. I was struck by the video of a young activist being egged- it could have been any one of my Tory friends. (Yes, I do have those.) Yet, at the top of its coverage, the BBC website used a photo of hooded anarchists who, in my experience, are always the minority on any large-scale demonstration. Though in their words, they emphasise the “largely peaceful” nature of their protest, the actions of the minority dominate the coverage. And so, in many people’s minds, the violent minority become the majority.

Now that might sound like a left-wing conspiracy theory. So I’ll illustrate the point with something which a story that is anything but that.

Back in 2010, at the height of student protests over tuition fees rises, me and a few friends decided to organise a walkout at our sixth-form college. We invited the local press. At first, it went well. In fact, we had so many supporters that we were overwhelmed. A few idiots decided to block the road. So all in all, it was ever so slightly catastrophic. With the local paper there, the best I was hoping for was they would quote my denunciations.

So how did they cover it? “Students block road in protest”? “Disorder at sixth form college”?

In fact, they wrote an editorial praising our political involvement. The coverage made no mention of those who blocked the road. The picture they chose showed a few of us peacefully holding placards.
The reporters were there. They took photographs of the car-blocking students. Yet an editorial decision was taken to cover just one side of the story.

Granted, the local press scene in Swansea is far from crowded. Even the title of the paper, “South Wales Evening Post” is a rather generous description of the readership. No other paper was there to cover the story. It’s true that those sort of decisions are unlikely to take place at the national level since any omissions will be made clear by rival newspaper coverage. But it underlines the point that coverage of demonstrations may not be consistent with what actually happens.

Zip forward a few weeks and I joined another 50,000 people at the official NUS demonstration in London. Yes, you know the one. The one where they stormed Tory HQ and someone threw a fire extinguisher at a policeman. Or rather, a breakaway group of 200 people left the official route and did their own idiotic thing. Guess which one made the headlines? “Violence at Tory HQ overshadows student fees protest” said the BBC. Other papers were not so generous. Of course they were right to cover it. But when the violent and ill thought-out actions of 200 people are given precedence over the other 49,800 who marched peacefully, inevitably the two become conflated. Another BBC headline illustrated the perils of this approach in another piece on “How the studentfees protest turned violent.” For the 49,800 of us who stayed on the official route, the protest didn’t turn violent. In fact, like many demonstrators, I was only vaguely aware of what was happening over at Millbank. And so it is easy to see how the actions of the minority come to be perceived as the actions of the majority.
 
Is this the result of overt political bias? Perhaps in some cases. But I think another bias is at work here- the bias to the story that sells. I know that’s a cliché, but it’s a cliché because it’s true. Violence will always outsell peaceful protest. No one is going to be tempted to watch the 6 o’clock news by people calmly holding placards.   The headline “Demonstrator calmly and eloquently condemns Conservative policies” will never make much headway outside of being shared on the Red Labour group on Facebook.
 
Some papers do valiantly go out of their way to ensure their reports are accurate and fair. But we need to be critical. The disorder seen at the Conservative conference does not represent the Left. It represents the minority. Please, don’t put us all in the same box.
 

Friday, 11 September 2015

Why I didn't vote for Jeremy Corbyn

I believe in high levels of public ownership, high taxes for the rich and I’m pretty liberal about immigration. I’m against Trident, the IMF and austerity. So, as the Labour Leadership election rattles towards its imminent conclusion, I’ve obviously voted Corbyn, right?

Actually, though my inner Bennite is turning in his temporary grave, I haven’t even given Jezza my second preference.

So what’s come over me? Have I finally, at the ripe old age of 21, given way to the right-winger within?

Far from it. I really appreciate what Corbyn has brought to this contest. At a time when I feared my party would bury its socialist past, Red Labour stands ready to take the helm.

The campaign against Corbyn has taken many forms. Much of it has been vitriolic and unfair. But some of it has been justified. Personally, I have doubts over whether such a divisive figure could ever provide Labour with one coherent message. While he may have the support of vast swathes of both the Party and the wider electorate, ultimately his effectiveness as leader depends on the loyalty of his own MPs. Without that, he risks leading an undisciplined Party that fails to deliver on its promises. Then he would let down the very people who to him to restore faith in politics.
Don’t get me wrong, I would love to see many of his policies implemented. But I worry that he won’t pick his battles, and will instead promise grand, unfeasible projects that will only cement the Left’s reputation as unrealistic.
But that’s not why my vote is going elsewhere.
 Even if he is elected as leader, Corbyn may not even survive long enough to write a manifesto, let alone fail to deliver it. But he would almost certainly lead Labour through the EU referendum, and the position he takes could well swing the vote one way or the other. Corbyn is the only candidate that has repeatedly failed to rule out campaigning for to leave the UK.

I understand why he hasn’t. He’s understandably concerned about Cameron’s attempts to whittle away EU workers’ rights. He is justifiably angry about the European Commission’s undemocratic attack on the Greek people. His opposition to the EU runs deeper, though, as his voting record makes abundantly clear.

Of course, I think the EU needs reform. It’s undemocratic and has too often favoured commercial interests over the rights of governments and citizens. But leaving the EU won’t change that. In fact, we may end up mimicking Norway’s “Fax democracy”, whereby EU regulations are adopted despite not having a voice in the European Parliament. But I think there’s a bigger problem with leaving the EU.
Corbyn’s issues with the EU seem to be fundamentally ideological. There’s nothing wrong with ideology. But it’s important to take a step back and consider why we have ideologies. Ultimately, I’m a socialist because I believe that it is the economic system that is best for the most vulnerable in society. It is that principle that must come first in any of my political beliefs. So while I worry about the neoliberal tendencies of the EU, I have to ask myself how withdrawal would affect the most vulnerable in society.

According to the Welsh European Funding office, EU funding has helped over 60,000 people back into work in Wales. While some EU money will have gone towards expensive vanity projects, much of it has gone to the most disadvantaged areas of Wales. It has funded hundreds of job creation schemes as well as research and development projects. In a small, poor country like Wales, the £500 million a year that we receive from the EU makes a massive difference. If we leave the EU, then we would most likely lose that money without compensation from the austerity-obsessed Conservative Government. Even a Labour Government would be hard pressed to plug the gap.

So I’m convinced that leaving the EU would hurt the most vulnerable in society. It would leave Britain out of the EU’s promising progress in the fight against climate change. If we leave the EU, then the very people that Corbyn wants to help will suffer.


Though I hate to say it, Corbyn is the wrong leader to guide us through the EU referendum. At any other time, I could overlook his beliefs about Europe. But not this time. 


Thursday, 30 July 2015

Calais Migrant Crisis: Barbarians at the Gates?

“Swarms.” That’s how David Cameron described the thousands of migrants at Calais. While he was swiftly condemned by Labour and human rights groups, some sections of the press have made his remarks seem positively welcoming. “Send in the Army,” bellows the Daily Mail with a characteristically mild-mannered and compassionate opinion piece that was mistakenly published instead of the news. “Send in the Gurkhas,” says the Telegraph in an article apparently ghostwritten by the East India Company at the height of Imperial expansion. The Sun, of course has its own take (well, Murdoch’s take), opting for a “headline” (“Softy Calais goes ballistic…Frenchies are atrocious”) that has all the coherency of a twelfth-century peasant on Facebook.

What is common to so much of the coverage is a chilling disregard for the humanity of these migrants. The Daily Mail talks of “asylum seekers being caught within 24 hours.” Never mind the fact that “asylum seeker” is the legal status for someone who is waiting for a decision on their application for asylum. Considering the number of migrants from Syria, Afghanistan and Libya who are trying to get into the country, it’s pretty obvious some of them will have a legitimate case. Not all of them, granted. As liberal as I am about immigration, I know we don’t have the resources to accommodate everyone who tries to get into the UK. But that doesn’t mean we can’t still treat them with respect. While I can understand the frustrations of those stuck at Calais, we’ve got to remember where the things that these people have been through to get here. Even those who may not be eligible for asylum have still gone to extremes to get where they are. They’ve suffered for it. That doesn’t excuse the behaviour of a minority who have been violent towards lorry drivers, but it should lead us to temper our response with maturity and compassion.

I know somebody who came into the UK in the back of a lorry. Before that, he had come to Europe in a people smugglers’ boat. Why? He was imprisoned in Iran for daring to renounce his Islamic faith. Rejected by his family and banned from following his new faith, he was unable to continue living in Iran. He was desperate. Since his asylum application was granted, rather than “living off welfare” he has worked tirelessly in low-paid jobs to support himself independently.

If that doesn’t convince you, just think of some of the other migrants trying to get into the UK through Calais. Over the last three months, the number of children seeking asylum and needing foster care after arriving in Dover has rocketed to 605. That’s more than twice as many as last year. Imagine it- children as young as twelve fleeing war-torn countries, being smuggled across Europe and then having to hide in the back of a lorry. All without a parent.

These are the people the papers have described as a threat. These are the people that the army would have to fight. But many of them are victims, whether they are eligible for asylum or not.

Yes, we have to deal with the queues at Calais. We’ve got to minimise disruption to holidaymakers and lorry drivers. And we’ll need to deport those who don’t qualify for asylum.


But none of that means we can’t treat people with dignity and respect.

Saturday, 11 July 2015

The Budget: Living within our means?

While this week’s slash and burn budget may have had a few surprises- a slower rate of deficit reduction, a new not-quite-living wage, and reforms to non-dom status- the rationale of this “long term economic plan” remains unchanged.  It goes something like this:

“We must live within our means. Families make cutbacks when household budgets are squeezed, so the country must do the same to avoid passing debt onto our children”

It makes sense. Even an idealistic left-winger like me has to admit that there is an undeniable logic to the argument. In the wake of the Great Recession, a crisis which saw so many plunged into unemployment and low pay, the comparison is particularly emotive. Families across the country know what it’s like to make difficult decisions about spending. Many will have made sacrifices to keep themselves and their children out of debt. They can relate to the idea that the country, like their households, has to “live within in its means”. And so the argument for cuts makes sense.

But the simplicity of this logic is deceptive. The country’s finances are not simply household budgets with a few extra trillion pounds. There are fundamental differences that bring into question the Government’s rationale for austerity. Families make cuts when their budgets are squeezed because they usually have no way of increasing their income. Given a choice between a promotion and cutbacks, few would opt for austerity.

The reality is that governments can increase their income in ways that families could never dream of. Consider tax avoidance and evasion, for example. I don’t know about you, but I’m not hiding any million-pound tax dodgers in my house. But the amount of uncollected tax is estimated by the HMRC to have been £34bn in 2012-2013. Of course, some of that will be down to small businesses or struggling individuals that might not be able to pay it back. But over £9bn was owed by large businesses and should, in theory, be easier to recover. Tax Research, in a study carried out on behalf of PCS, estimated that illegal tax evasion cost the UK £82 billion in the 2013-14 tax year. And that’s before we take into account that corporations like Amazon and Starbucks legally avoid through “creative” tax arrangements. 

How can it be responsible to slash benefits for the disabled while billions in tax remain unpaid each year? How can we cut in-work benefits for the low-paid while the very companies that pay their meagre wages don’t pay their fair share of tax?

By constantly referring to the country’s finances in terms of a household budget, the Conservatives can avoid these sort of questions. It’s been repeated so many times that cuts seem are seen by many to be the obvious solution. Yet the argument is shaky when we consider the power of the government to raise revenue. More worryingly, while the government preaches responsibility to so many, austerity isn’t the most responsible choice. They claim that cuts are necessary for the economy to grow. And yet the Office for Budget Responsibility say the pace of large cuts will lead to lower quarterly growth in next year. Even the IMF, hardly a bastion of socialism, has noted that countries with pro-growth policies recovered more quickly from the recession than those engaged in public sector cuts. Lower growth leads to lower tax returns, which goes some way towards explaining why the government has so drastically missed its target to balance the books by 2015. Even now, the OBR has calculated that there is just a 55% chance that they will hit their targets this time.

Some might say that focusing on dealing with tax avoidance is anti-business. Of course, some companies might scale back their operations if tax regulations were tightened up.  However, it’s equally true that others might flourish in their place. Tax avoidance is anti-competitive because it gives some companies (usually the ones with the most expensive lawyers and accountants) an unfair advantage. How can local booksellers compete with Amazon when they pay such different levels of tax? Even large businesses which shun tax avoidance and evasion must work harder to compete with the likes of Starbucks.  

It’s true the left sometimes talk about tax as if the government could just find a few billion behind the back of the sofa. Of course, it’s not that simple. We should avoid tokenistic, crowd-pleasing measures that lose more money than they gain. We can’t just reclaim billions overnight. Tax evasion is not designed to, well, evade. We won’t get all of it back. But the staggering figures involved show that there is something seriously wrong with the idea that austerity is the only responsible way to deal with the national debt. It is proof that we have more options open to us than the Chancellor would dare to admit.

Some of these solutions wouldn’t be easy. But when the financial arrangements of corporations like Google are spelled out in newspaper exposes, we can at least begin to close the loopholes we know about. Whether we do or not is a question of political willpower.

It has to be said that George Osborne has made some efforts to reclaim some of the billions lost in tax avoidance and evasion every year. But these programmes barely scrape the surface of the tax gap. And just how is HM Revenue and Customs meant to deal with tax avoidance and evasion when it is set to lose a fifth of its staff? Yes- the Government really is trying to put itself back into the black by cutting the very people who collect our taxes.


Difficult decisions- that is so often the euphemism of choice to describe the cuts agenda. And yet Wednesday’s budget was surprisingly lacking in difficult decisions. Why? The most difficult decisions would have the cost the Conservative Party much of their own vote. Dealing with the tax gap- that would have been part of the “One Nation” solution. But instead the chancellor opted for easier alternatives- cutting tax credits, cutting child benefit, cutting disability allowances…

Difficult decisions?

Hardly. Each of these measures hits the Labour vote the hardest. It’s true that the Budget did announce a tightening of the rules on non-doms (those living in the UK but not paying tax due to an archaic loophole). But he stopped short of abolishing the status completely. Besides, non-dom status, although well-known, is little more than the tip of the iceberg. There remain far too many individuals and companies willing to freeride on the tax paid by those less fortunate than them. 

What about the  giveaways of the budget? The IFS calculates that cutting tax credits will leave many people worse even despite a higher minimum wage. Changes to inheritance tax and a cut in the higher rate of tax suggests George Osborne is once again offering an alternative to austerity for those most likely to vote Tory.


So much for a “One Nation” budget. 

Monday, 11 May 2015

Why did the Conservatives win? (No it's not because the electorate are evil)

At 10pm on Thursday, just as the polls closed and the exit polls were announced, the post-match analysis began. Labour had lost Scotland- that was clear. Soon, as successive target remained stubbornly blue, it became obvious that Labour had lost England and Wales as well.

And then came the condemnation. Britain had become no more than “an aggregation of self-interest” proclaimed Reverend Giles Fraser in the Guardian. With less eloquence, thousands of statuses and tweets condemned the “selfish” and “narrow-minded” voters. According to them, when faced with the choice, the electorate had voted against compassion in favour of austerity. How could they be so callous, so ignorant, so self-centred?

Call me an optimist, but I can’t bring myself to believe this cynical version of events. Don’t get me wrong- I hate what the Conservatives have done over the last five years. I think they do stand up for the rich. And yes, of course, like many, I posted a status expressing my despair. And I have definitely generalised Conservative voters. (I’m sorry to say it’s often been intentional on my part.)

Though it may go against the left-wing inclinations of some Labour supporters, myself included, we’ve got to recognise that the majority of people voted Tory out of good intentions. No doubt, some people were motivated by selfishness. But the same could be said of any party. And we’ve got to remember that floating voters continue to play a decisive role in democracy. Did the Conservatives secure a majority with a swing of just 0.8% because 0.8% more people are now more selfish than they were 5 years ago? No, I don’t think so.

The Conservatives won because they had a clear and emotive argument. In essence, it was this: “Labour overspent. By “living beyond their means” they caused the recession. As a result, we’ve had to make difficult choices. It’s been tough but we’ve saved the economy. Vote Labour and they will ruin the economy once again”.
Whatever you think of the starting premise, you can’t deny it’s coherent. More than that, it’s emotive. Those who saw their wages cut during the recession know what it’s like to make difficult choices. When they earned less, they spent less. By applying this logic to the economy, the Conservatives have turned something complex into to something everyone can relate to.

If voters accept this line of reasoning, then all of Labour’s good intentions will come to nothing. If Labour caused the last recession, then they won’t be able to deliver the strong economy they need to carry out their promises. Zero hours contracts, lower tuition fees, affordable housing- each one is meaningless idealism if you believe that a Labour Government would drag us back to the chaos of 2009. The Conservatives have presented the electorate with a clear choice between austerity and the economic meltdown. With the best of intentions, they chose the lesser of two evils. And we can’t judge them for that. 

Yes, the logic of the Conservative argument “makes sense”. It’s coherent. It’s emotive.
But it’s based on a series of lie that shamelessly distort the truth. Labour didn’t overspend- in fact, between 1997 and 2003, on average, they kept the books balanced. It’s true that the deficit did rise in the years leading up to 2007. But only by 3% of GDP, which that was far from country-crippling levels. In fact, by 2007 Labour had achieved lower levels of borrowing than they had inherited from the Conservatives.

Of course, then the recession hit. But did Labour cause the global recession? No, it was only during the recession the deficit hit such high levels. Why? Rising unemployment was pushing up the welfare bill to rise just as tax revenues were falling.  The same would have happened to any government. Of course, Labour was forced to bail out the banks. But by doing so, they made sure that the savings of millions of people and thousands of businesses were safe. And so, by 2010, the economy was slowly growing again. So if spending wasn’t out of control, then how did Labour ruin the economy? The short answer is that they didn’t. Now of course I would say that (I’m a raving lefty). I’m also clearly not an economist. Just listen to theNobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman, who described the Conservative argument as  “delusional”. The Cambridge economist Ha Joon Chang calls it an “economic fairytale”. Sir Nicholas MacPherson, the non-partisan Permanent Secretary to the Treasury, is clear that the recession was caused by a “banking crisis pure and simple”.

 And of course there are so many flaws with comparing the public finances to a household. True, when households face financial difficulties, they make cutbacks. But unlike households, governments can increase their income. I don’t know about you, but there are no tax avoiding millionaires in my home. There are limits to how much we can tax and how much we can invest. The balance between cuts, investment and taxation is up for debate.

But one thing is clear- rather than ruining the economy, Labour saved it.

But you wouldn’t have guessed that from the way Labour spoke about it. For the last five years, the Party has allowed the Conservative’s deceitful narrative to dominate the public debate. Far from challenging it, they’ve apologised for it. So much of their election campaign was spent saying “sorry, we’ll do better next time”.

By the last TV debates, when Miliband finally did argue that Labour hadn’t caused the recession. But it was too little, too late. By then, the Conservatives’ argument had become so mainstream that Miliband seemed to be going against common sense. So the audience, and then the electorate, judged him to be economically incapable.

If Labour had fought the Conservatives’ narrative earlier, if their version of events had been challenged outside of the Guardian and the Independent, then maybe the Conservatives would have been seen as the Party with the ‘ludicrous’ argument.

In a democratic country, political parties and politicians shouldn’t just follow the public debate. They should inform it, lead it and even challenge it. Instead, Labour gave in and apologised for something they had never done.

No wonder the electorate judged them economically incompetent. Yes, democracy has failed us. But not because voters are selfish, callous or stupid. For the last 5 years, we have been presented with a series of lies by the Conservative media. The failure of democracy began when both Labour and the media left those pseudo-facts unchallenged.


If anything, it is democracy that has failed the voters, not vice versa.  

Sunday, 19 April 2015

Is Britain full? Wrong question


“Ed Miliband, do you think Britain is full? Supposing we got to a figure of 70 million in 10 or 15 years, is that acceptable? 75 million? 80 million? 95 million? 100 million”

That’s the question that Jeremy Paxman put to Miliband in the recent leaders’ interviews. It’s a question the Labour leader refused to answer. Why should he? It’s a stupid question. Is Britain full?! What on earth does mean? There are less than 700 people per square mile in the UK. That doesn’t sound very full. Particularly when we remember that in Monoco, that figure is 50,000. Of course, Paxman wasn’t talking about space. He was talking about resources. But then again, “Do you think that Britain has the resources to cope with modest population growth in a country that has grown by 50 million in the last two centuries?” doesn’t have quite the same ring,.

So instead he made it seem like accepting a new immigrant into Britain means pushing someone else into the North Sea.

It’s the sort of question a twelfth-century peasant might ask when 10 newcomers walked into his village. After all, back then, this seemingly-overcrowded isle had a population of just 3.5 million then. Now that figure is 65 million.

“Is Britain full?” a medieval Paxman might have asked. “Supposing we got to a figure of 4 million in 10 or 15 years, is that acceptable? 6 million? 10 million? 20 million?”  

Now you may say that this comparison is a little extreme. Of course, population change over centuries is different to population change over decades. But it highlights the intrinsically subjective nature of Paxman’s question. To us, it might not seem like we have the capacity to cope with a growing population. But then the medieval peasant would have said the same. As might a Londoner before the onset of the Industrial revolution. Our own perceptions about whether Britain is “full” are frankly meaningless.

But surely population growth has been significantly higher in recent times? Not really. Between 1911 and 2011, the population of England and Wales grew by 27 million. To us, that may seem staggering. But it’s hardly historically unprecedented.  In fact, it’s barely an increase on what we saw in the hundred years before 1911, when population grew by 26 million. That’s even more remarkable when we consider the growth in relative terms. Between 1811 and 1911, Britain’s population more than tripled. That's what you call unprecedented. By contrast, our population hasn’t even doubled over the last century. And even that growth has been fairly stable.


Of course, the population growth during the Industrial Revolution did have a serious impact on living conditions. But even the most apocalyptic warnings over immigration don’t talk of anything like that. Britain is richer today. Both social protection and public services are stronger today.  We coped then and we are better able to cope today. And so history hasn’t repeated itself over the last century. Neither am I inclined to think it will do over the next.
Is Britain full? It’s more than the wrong question. In the context in the immigration debate, it’s a particularly odious thing to ask. Instead of addressing the issue, it exploits our fears, pitting “us” against “them”. Fundamentally, it’s a question that is designed to scaremonger and scapegoat.

Though the question claims to be about overpopulation, it clearly isn’t. Immigration isn’t the only cause of a growing population. It’s not even the biggest cause, not by a long shot. From what we’ve heard I the debates, we probably all know that net migration is running at 300,000 a year. But what we don’t hear so often is just how many people are born each year. In 2013, there were 810,000 births across the UK. You do hear it said sometimes that immigrants tend to have larger families, but there’s no way that this could be a significant factor in those 810,000 births. The fact is, people have babies. Even British people. They will carry on doing so.  As they have done throughout human history.

If politicians genuinely thought that overpopulation was a problem, manifesto pledges would include a one child policy and forced sterilisation.

So why do we insist on asking if Britain is too “full”? Why do we think that Britain can’t adapt to new levels of immigration?  Nobody question whether it can adapt to new births. Why? Because everyone knows that those children will go on to contribute economically and culturally to this country.  So do immigrants. In fact, they are on average net contributors. Of course, a country takes time to adapt to a larger population. Any movement of people has an impact on the labour market.  There are many challenges and so we need to make sure that immigration is fair and sustainable for everyone involved.  Issues like housing need attention for all our sakes.  Some controls on immigrations are necessary to make sure that all of us, immigrants included, can continue to contribute to this country and enjoy its benefits.  Exactly which controls we need is a different question. I’m not trying to weigh up the pros and cons of immigration here. What I am saying is that we won’t reach some level when Britain becomes ‘full’ and we have to start chucking immigrants into the English Channel. We need to be wary when politicians and the media give us that impression.


There is certainly nothing wrong with debating immigration. I think, in the past, staying silent on its challenges has done more harm than good. So it is completely right for us to look for answers to tough questions. But before we start pitting ourselves against each other, let’s make sure that the question that we ask are the right ones.