Saturday, 14 November 2015

Responding to Tragedy: Are We Just Biased to the West?



As France enters three days of national mourning, it seems as if so much of the world has joined them in solidarity. While everyone agrees that the Paris were tragedies acts that deserve our righteous anger and grief, some have questioned why we haven’t responded to Thursday’s attacks in Beirut with the outpouring of sympathy. With ISIS claiming responsibility for both, it’s an understandable question. But I’m sceptical of those just blaming racism or a  conscious bias to the West. I think our response is more nuanced and more morally justifiable than that.

Is the media just biased to the problems of the West? Most likely, there’s some truth in that, but I think the issue is more complicated that it’s made out to be.  The reality is, that the attacks in Beirut were just a small part of the many acts of violence happening across the world this week. On Friday, a suicide bombing claimed 19 lives in Baghdad. Syria’s bloody civil war continues. Burundi, according to the UN, seems to be on the verge of perpetrating acts of genocide. The list goes on. Even if the news had focused on Beirut and Paris in equal measures, it would still have failed to cover most other acts of mass murder. If the news reported every single atrocity in the world, then bulletins would be no more than a list of tragedies. They wouldn’t have time to explore the suffering caused by each one.  Where would be the dignity in that?  News outlets have to prioritise however much they try to report with balance and fairness. So they will choose to report the extraordinary. It’s far from perfect. Undoubtedly, subconscious biases and the pursuit of profit will play a part. It’s difficult to see a way around. At least the internet gives us access to alternative sources of information that can help counteract those biases.

But what about our emotional responses to attacks like this? Do we just care more about people “like us” who die? Again, I think it’s more complicated than that. If it’s difficult for the media to report every atrocity going the world, it’s even more impossible for us to emotionally engage with every tragedy that happens each day. They call it compassion fatigue. We see so many images of victims that we become numb to their suffering. At best, we muster a reverent but short-lived sympathy when we see reports of horrors that we are powerless to change. We know that’s not right. But it’s simply impossible to live our lives constantly empathising with those who are suffering in this world.
However, because we know that we can’t respond appropriately to every horror we see each day, rather than do nothing, we decide to engage fully with a small part of the suffering we see in the world.  There are many factors which affect what we choose to respond to, but two in particular stand out for me. Firstly, we respond when we think our response can change something. Secondly, we respond when the suffering is closest to us. I think our reaction to the refugee crisis illustrates this perfectly. We all know about the terrible ongoing civil war in Syria. We all vaguely know about the lives of people under oppressive regimes like Iran and Saudi Arabia. And we all have an idea about the desperate poverty of so many people in developing nations. But the suffering was so immense and so far away that we felt powerless to change anything. However, when we saw those same people drowning in the Mediterranean Sea, that suffering was suddenly in our backyard. More than that, it seemed like it was preventable. And so, suddenly, there was a public emotional engagement with the issue.  We donated, we volunteered and collectively our anger and sadness pressured European leaders into acting. The crisis isn’t solved, but we can be sure that our emotional engagement mattered. Did we think of any refugee as a lesser human being before they decided to cross the Mediterranean Sea? No, but we felt that our emotional engagement could do little to stop their suffering. But when their suffering was both preventable and in our backyard, we decided to care.

So how does this relate to Paris? We know that terrorism is evil. We want to respond to that. But In a world of twenty-four hour news, when atrocities are so frequently reported, we are numb to the full extent of the suffering terrorism causes. We find it particularly hard to feel the effects of terrorism when we are so far away. That’s the case with the attacks in Beirut and Baghdad. We know it’s awful, but we just can’t relate to the extent of the suffering terrorism causes.

But it’s different when it happens in Paris. It’s in our backyard. Like many of my fellow students in Paris, so many people have messaged me to check if I’m safe. Many of us will know someone in Paris, but not so many of us will know someone in Beirut.  So the attacks feel more real because the possibility of losing somebody is much higher. Even if we don’t know anyone in Paris, most of us have been there. As a result, it feels more real to us. More than that, we know that the victims were leading similar lives to us. They were killed in the type of places that we visit. So we see more clearly how our lives can be suddenly and tragically cuts short. That may not be the case when attacks happen with very different cultures. When attacks happen in places that are geographically or culturally close to us, they feel more real to us. So it’s easier for us to engage emotionally with it.

It’s the same when we a friend loses someone close to them. Even if we’ve never met the person they’ve lost, we can share in their grief and try to comfort them. Why? Because we see the effects of that loss on someone we love, and so are better able to understanding what they’re going through. A stranger’s bereavement may be just as devastating for them, but however hard we try, we can’t feel it in the same way.


So we need to be careful before we devalue someone’s sympathy by saying that it’s biased to “people like them”. We can’t respond to everything, and so when we do respond to something, it may well be because we have something in common with the person who’s suffering. Maybe that’s the way we deal with the scale of human suffering around us. Maybe that’s just our imperfect response to an imperfect world. 

No comments:

Post a Comment