While this week’s slash and burn budget may have had a few
surprises- a slower rate of deficit reduction, a new not-quite-living wage, and
reforms to non-dom status- the rationale of this “long term economic plan”
remains unchanged. It goes something
like this:
“We must live within our means. Families make cutbacks when
household budgets are squeezed, so the country must do the same to avoid
passing debt onto our children”
It makes sense. Even an idealistic left-winger like me has
to admit that there is an undeniable logic to the argument. In the wake of the
Great Recession, a crisis which saw so many plunged into unemployment and low
pay, the comparison is particularly emotive. Families across the country know
what it’s like to make difficult decisions about spending. Many will have made
sacrifices to keep themselves and their children out of debt. They can relate
to the idea that the country, like their households, has to “live within in its
means”. And so the argument for cuts makes sense.

But the simplicity of this logic is deceptive. The country’s
finances are not simply household budgets with a few extra trillion pounds.
There are fundamental differences that bring into question the Government’s rationale
for austerity. Families make cuts when their budgets are squeezed because they
usually have no way of increasing their income. Given a choice between a
promotion and cutbacks, few would opt for austerity.
The reality is that governments can increase their income in
ways that families could never dream of. Consider tax avoidance and evasion,
for example. I don’t know about you, but I’m not hiding any million-pound tax
dodgers in my house. But the amount of uncollected tax is estimated by the HMRC
to have been £34bn in 2012-2013. Of course, some of that will be down to small
businesses or struggling individuals that might not be able to pay it back. But
over £9bn was owed by large businesses and should, in theory, be easier to
recover. Tax Research, in a study carried out on behalf of PCS, estimated that
illegal tax evasion cost the UK £82 billion in the 2013-14 tax year. And that’s
before we take into account that corporations like Amazon and Starbucks legally
avoid through “creative” tax arrangements.
How can it be responsible to slash benefits for the disabled
while billions in tax remain unpaid each year? How can we cut in-work benefits
for the low-paid while the very companies that pay their meagre wages don’t pay
their fair share of tax?
By constantly referring to the country’s finances in terms
of a household budget, the Conservatives can avoid these sort of questions. It’s
been repeated so many times that cuts seem are seen by many to be the obvious solution.
Yet the argument is shaky when we consider the power of the government to raise
revenue. More worryingly, while the government preaches responsibility to so many,
austerity isn’t the most responsible choice. They claim that cuts are necessary
for the economy to grow. And yet the Office for Budget Responsibility say the
pace of large cuts will lead to lower quarterly growth in next year. Even the
IMF, hardly a bastion of socialism, has noted that countries with pro-growth
policies recovered more quickly from the recession than those engaged in public
sector cuts. Lower growth leads to lower tax returns, which goes some way towards
explaining why the government has so drastically missed its target to balance
the books by 2015. Even now, the OBR has calculated that there is just a 55%
chance that they will hit their targets this time.
Some might say that focusing on dealing with tax avoidance
is anti-business. Of course, some companies might scale back their operations
if tax regulations were tightened up. However,
it’s equally true that others might flourish in their place. Tax avoidance is
anti-competitive because it gives some companies (usually the ones with the
most expensive lawyers and accountants) an unfair advantage. How can local
booksellers compete with Amazon when they pay such different levels of tax?
Even large businesses which shun tax avoidance and evasion must work harder to
compete with the likes of Starbucks.
It’s true the left sometimes talk about tax as if the
government could just find a few billion behind the back of the sofa. Of
course, it’s not that simple. We should avoid tokenistic, crowd-pleasing
measures that lose more money than they gain. We can’t just reclaim billions
overnight. Tax evasion is not designed to, well, evade. We won’t get all of it
back. But the staggering figures involved show that there is something
seriously wrong with the idea that austerity is the only responsible way to
deal with the national debt. It is proof that we have more options open to us
than the Chancellor would dare to admit.
Some of these solutions wouldn’t be easy. But when the
financial arrangements of corporations like Google are spelled out in newspaper
exposes, we can at least begin to close the loopholes we know about. Whether we
do or not is a question of political willpower.
It has to be said that George Osborne has made some efforts
to reclaim some of the billions lost in tax avoidance and evasion every year.
But these programmes barely scrape the surface of the tax gap. And just how is
HM Revenue and Customs meant to deal with tax avoidance and evasion when it is
set to lose a fifth of its staff? Yes- the Government really is trying to put
itself back into the black by cutting the very people who collect our taxes.
Difficult decisions- that is so often the euphemism of
choice to describe the cuts agenda. And yet Wednesday’s budget was surprisingly
lacking in difficult decisions. Why? The most difficult decisions would have
the cost the Conservative Party much of their own vote. Dealing with the tax
gap- that would have been part of the “One Nation” solution. But instead the
chancellor opted for easier alternatives- cutting tax credits, cutting child
benefit, cutting disability allowances…
Difficult decisions?
Hardly. Each of these measures hits the Labour vote the hardest.
It’s true that the Budget did announce a tightening of the rules on non-doms
(those living in the UK but not paying tax due to an archaic loophole). But he
stopped short of abolishing the status completely. Besides, non-dom status,
although well-known, is little more than the tip of the iceberg. There remain
far too many individuals and companies willing to freeride on the tax paid by those
less fortunate than them.
What about the giveaways of the budget? The IFS calculates that
cutting tax credits will leave many people worse even despite a higher minimum
wage. Changes to inheritance tax and a cut in the higher rate of tax suggests
George Osborne is once again offering an alternative to austerity for those
most likely to vote Tory.
So much for a “One Nation” budget.