Wednesday, 7 October 2015

Spitting lefties?

“Don’t believe everything you read in the paper”

I’m usually skeptical. Not skeptical of the press, but skeptical of those who are skeptical. I don’t want to believe that everyone is lying to me. And I find it curious that I’m only implored to be skeptical whenever I suggest an alternative point of view.

However, this week’s coverage of the Conservative conference made me think of my own experiences of protesting and the way in which coverage can be distorted. Every newspaper was keen to point out that the spitting, the verbal abuse and the egg-throwing were only the actions of a small minority. The organisers of the protest rightfully condemned this behaviour. Without a doubt, it was awful. I was struck by the video of a young activist being egged- it could have been any one of my Tory friends. (Yes, I do have those.) Yet, at the top of its coverage, the BBC website used a photo of hooded anarchists who, in my experience, are always the minority on any large-scale demonstration. Though in their words, they emphasise the “largely peaceful” nature of their protest, the actions of the minority dominate the coverage. And so, in many people’s minds, the violent minority become the majority.

Now that might sound like a left-wing conspiracy theory. So I’ll illustrate the point with something which a story that is anything but that.

Back in 2010, at the height of student protests over tuition fees rises, me and a few friends decided to organise a walkout at our sixth-form college. We invited the local press. At first, it went well. In fact, we had so many supporters that we were overwhelmed. A few idiots decided to block the road. So all in all, it was ever so slightly catastrophic. With the local paper there, the best I was hoping for was they would quote my denunciations.

So how did they cover it? “Students block road in protest”? “Disorder at sixth form college”?

In fact, they wrote an editorial praising our political involvement. The coverage made no mention of those who blocked the road. The picture they chose showed a few of us peacefully holding placards.
The reporters were there. They took photographs of the car-blocking students. Yet an editorial decision was taken to cover just one side of the story.

Granted, the local press scene in Swansea is far from crowded. Even the title of the paper, “South Wales Evening Post” is a rather generous description of the readership. No other paper was there to cover the story. It’s true that those sort of decisions are unlikely to take place at the national level since any omissions will be made clear by rival newspaper coverage. But it underlines the point that coverage of demonstrations may not be consistent with what actually happens.

Zip forward a few weeks and I joined another 50,000 people at the official NUS demonstration in London. Yes, you know the one. The one where they stormed Tory HQ and someone threw a fire extinguisher at a policeman. Or rather, a breakaway group of 200 people left the official route and did their own idiotic thing. Guess which one made the headlines? “Violence at Tory HQ overshadows student fees protest” said the BBC. Other papers were not so generous. Of course they were right to cover it. But when the violent and ill thought-out actions of 200 people are given precedence over the other 49,800 who marched peacefully, inevitably the two become conflated. Another BBC headline illustrated the perils of this approach in another piece on “How the studentfees protest turned violent.” For the 49,800 of us who stayed on the official route, the protest didn’t turn violent. In fact, like many demonstrators, I was only vaguely aware of what was happening over at Millbank. And so it is easy to see how the actions of the minority come to be perceived as the actions of the majority.
 
Is this the result of overt political bias? Perhaps in some cases. But I think another bias is at work here- the bias to the story that sells. I know that’s a cliché, but it’s a cliché because it’s true. Violence will always outsell peaceful protest. No one is going to be tempted to watch the 6 o’clock news by people calmly holding placards.   The headline “Demonstrator calmly and eloquently condemns Conservative policies” will never make much headway outside of being shared on the Red Labour group on Facebook.
 
Some papers do valiantly go out of their way to ensure their reports are accurate and fair. But we need to be critical. The disorder seen at the Conservative conference does not represent the Left. It represents the minority. Please, don’t put us all in the same box.