On Wednesday, the House of Commons voted for War. Or maybe
it was for Peace in Syria. They voted to kill innocent civilians. Or maybe it
was to protect them. They voted to attack yet Muslim country. Or maybe they
voted to defend our own people.
Whether it was Corbyn’s “Terrorist sympathisers” or
Cameron’s “Western warmongers”, inside the House and out of it, oversimplifications
have been in abundance these last few days. While I’m not in favour of the
strikes, I’ve been annoyed by so many black-and-white characterisations of last
night’s vote. Many, including Corbyn himself, have given passionate and
principled arguments against the strikes.
Crucially, they respected their colleagues’ different opinions. Rather
than demonising those who disagreed with them, they recognised the equally
strong moral conviction of their opponents.
But not everyone been so nuanced in their understanding. I
find it unbelievable that so many people have dismissed supporters of the
strike as immoral warmongers. Do they honestly believe that MPs walked through
the voting lobby thinking gleefully about killing Syrian children? How can they
think that anyone could take that decision lightly? Just think of those MPs
that decided to vote for the strike. As a Labour leadership candidate, Yvette
Cooper put her head above the parapet by calling for the UK to accept 10,000 refugees.
Lib-Dems like Tim Farron took a strong moral stand against the Iraq War but
voted in favour of strikes. As Secretary for International Development, Hillary
Benn dramatically increased spending on foreign aid.*
Can we really say any of these people are no more than
heartless warmongers? Are they any less sincere? Are they any less moral?
Pacifists believe that only non-violence can bring about a
more peaceful world. Fair enough. But we have to remember that it is not only
pacifists who want peace in Syria and Iraq. Those who voted for the strikes did
so because they sincerely believe that limited military action, although
undesirable, would be the most effective way of defeating ISIS and bring about
peace in the long run. Of course we may well disagree with that. But we have to
remember that people with the same aims can come to different conclusions. It
is incredibly arrogant to suggest that your own conclusion is the only moral
conclusion.
Again, I know this doesn’t represent the opinions of all
pacifists, let alone those non-pacifists who opposed the strikes. But if we
really want a “kinder and gentler politics”, we can start by avoiding
inaccurate and offensive characterisations of our opponents.
So let’s be clear about a few things. For a start,
politicians didn’t vote for “War.” They didn’t need to do that. There already
was a war. And that war would have carried on regardless of how MPs voted. In
fact, MPs were deciding how to bring about an end to that war. Many of them decided
that extending targeted military strikes could do that. Of course, others weren’t convinced. But it
was clear from the many passionate speeches of MPs on both sides of the debate
wanted the same thing- peace.
Neither did they choose War over Peace. As was clear from
speeches on both sides of the debate, everyone wanted a “comprehensive political
settlement” to the crisis in Syria. But even with a comprehensive peace
agreement, the question over what to do with ISIS would remain. ISIS will not
negotiate. Moreover, we (rightly) wouldn’t let them. A peace agreement that
didn’t take into account ISIS would just let them conquer the rest of Syria
more easily. Pro-strike MPs want a political settlement, but they believe there
are limits to that settlement. That is not the same as trying to “bomb their
way” out of a crisis.
They didn’t vote to kill innocent civilians. I find it hard
to believe how many people have accused them of doing just that. They voted for
targeted strikes against ISIS. Yes, that may result in civilian deaths. But
those deaths would be not be intentional. Of course, civilian casualties are
tragedies regardless of whether they are targeted deliberately or not. However,
morally, voting for targeted airstrikes that may unintentionally kill civilians
is different to deliberately targeting civilians. That’s not what the vote was
about. Do we honestly think that those who voted in favour the strikes sought to
emulate Bashar al-Assad’s shelling of civilians in Homs? Do we think they have
ceased to care about Syrian refugees because they voted to carry out targeted attacks?
No. They made the
judgement that the strikes would save far more civilians than they would kill. We
may disagree with that judgement. But the fact remains that they took that
decision with the aim of saving civilian lives. They aren’t evil for thinking
that. We need to draw a distinction between our local MP and the likes of
Bashar al-Assad.
Of course there were plenty of perfectly good reasons for
opposing the strikes. Personally, I felt that those in favour of the strikes
made a strong moral argument without making a strong military case for action.
It was assumed that ISIS could be defeated just by increasing the number of
airstrikes. However, experts from King’s College London’s Department of War
Studies questioned Cameron’s strategy. A former senior CIA official even questioned
whether the strikes would really be help to make Britain more secure.**
But we have to recognise that MPs on both sides of the debate
were motivated by the same desire to protect the people of Syria and the UK.
Those of us who think the strikes will make things worse
should be humble. We have to remember that many others want the best for Syria.
More than that, maybe we should hope that our fears will be proven to be unjustified.
Maybe, for once, we should hope that we are wrong.
* Many on the left have criticised Benn for passionately
arguing for something his father, “the real Benn”, would have passionately opposed.
But anyone who reads anything by Tony Benn, a politician who was the paragon of decency,
will quickly realise that he loved his son and respected his convictions. He
would be deeply upset by the way those on the left have talked about him
**I was going to talk more about what I didn’t think more strikes were a good idea, but I’ve spoken far too much already. (As always.) Just watch Richard Burgen MP’s 4 minute speech here and you’ll know what I think:


