Saturday, 22 October 2016

Refugees in Paris


Paris, the City of Love, is a place of contrast and contradiction. While kings and emperors have fallen here, this epicentre of sedition is reactionary in design. With boulevards too wide to barricade and Roman-style straight roads intended to speed up a marching army, Paris was made for the ruthless suppression of dissent. Though the history of France, perhaps more so than any other nation, is a history of class struggle, at its heart is a city that reeks of the bourgeois.  And it was in Paris, the European capital of glamour and fashion, that I first saw a whole family begging on the streets of Western Europe.

From Oscar Wilde to Ayatollah Khomeini, Paris has long been the sanctuary de luxe for the most sophisticated of exiles. Today its refugees are of a rather different sort. Even outside the exclusive boutiques of central Paris, it is not uncommon to see parents with their toddlers, sharing a mattress, wrapped in dirty blankets, holding out coffee cups of small change and begging to pay for their daily bread.  I don’t know if they are all asylum seekers.  I don’t know if they are recent arrivals or if they have been in the country for years. But it cannot be a coincidence that the overwhelming majority of them are from North Africa and the Middle-East.

Earlier this year, I volunteered with Sciences Po Refugee Help, a group set up by a handful of inspirational students from my university in Paris. I say volunteering- I did little more than watch while others who know more and speak more languages than me (I’ve yet to find those elusive Welsh-speaking refugees) help desperate people apply for asylum in France. Like the other volunteers, my eyes have been opened to a side of the refugee crisis that rarely makes it onto our television screens.


While government guidelines promise housing to each person who applies for asylum, most are have no option but to live in makeshift “refugee camps”.  Though the number varies from day to day, sometimes more a hundred people residents live in these unofficial camps hidden in the backstreets of Paris. When I visited one of these camps, now “evacuated” by the Parisian police, I saw cardboard “mattresses” and worn-out sleeping bags that promised little warmth in the midst of winter. The collective hardship of this squalor can result in a moving comradery between people thrown together out of sheer desperation. One Pakistani man was asked whether he got on with his Afghan neighbours. “Here, we become friends,” he said.

There were surprisingly few women and children in that camp. The men would brave the bitter cold while the proceeds of the day’s begging would go towards finding their families a basic room for the night. Some are not so “lucky”.  Not only do whole families end up on the street, children also end up alone.  In theory, every new arrival under the age of 18 is guaranteed a bed for the night. But stretched resources have left the authorities eager to screen out potential adults. When someone travels for two thousand miles on foot or in the back of a lorry, their documents don’t always survive the journey. Nor do refugees always flee warzones carrying their passport.  Even for those who do have their papers, there is no guarantee of shelter. The overstretched housing centres prioritise the youngest, meaning those over the age of 14 have a slim chance of being given a bed. And so they are left on the street. 

With the announcement plans for two official asylum centres housing 1,000 refugees, things seem to be improving in Paris. But the same scenes are repeated in towns and cities across Europe. The crisis is far from over.

Of the one million refugees entering Europe last year, 27% were under the age of 18. With thousands making the journey without their parents, these vulnerable children make ripe pickings for organised crime. Over the past two years, a complicated criminal network has developed to exploit our failure to solve the refugee crisis.  According to Europol, 10,000 refugee children are missing in Europe, trafficked into slavery or underage sex work.


Meanwhile, some in the UK are suggesting dental checks to verify the age of 100 refugee children. With 10,000 kids being sexually abused or enslaved by criminals, David Davies MP is worried that “British hospitality is being abused”.


Friday, 22 April 2016

Brexit, Port Talbot and the Rest of Wales

Like anyone from Swansea, I’m well acquainted with the ugly-lovely landmark that is the Tata steelworks. While in my hometown, formerly Copper-opolis, our metal-making prowess gathers asbestos-laden dust, the steam of heavy industry still shrouds the blast furnaces of Port Talbot. (Port Tahl-butt, that is, mind you. We’ll have none of this “Port Tall-bert” business, thank you, Mr BBC-English.)

As I’ve watched the coverage of Tata’s decision to close its UK plants, I’m worried by the way the steel crisis has become just another anti-EU story. The Daily Mail and rest of the Brussels-bashing press are only interested in the struggling post-industrial communities of South Wales when it fits in with their political agenda.  Boris Johnson, that well-known defender of the proletariat, wrote a lengthy status expressing sympathy with the workers before jumping on the bandwagon and warning that “at every turn we have the problem of the EU.”

While I don’t know a lot about steel production, I do know about the EU and, above all, I know Wales. Although I believe there are many legitimate reasons for wanting to leave the EU, I’m annoyed by the way some politicians have painted leaving the EU as the solution to all of Port Talbot’s troubles. Even if Brexit could save the TATA steelworks (and UK Steel says it wouldn’t), the trauma of leaving the EU would still wreak havoc on areas like Port Talbot.

Those of us who love Wales have to be honest about its flaws, and the fact is, Wales is poor. Unemployment here is higher than in the rest of the UK. As recently as 2013, the jobless rate in Blaenau Gwent reached 15%, showing just how precarious employment in the South Wales valleys can be. But even that fails to express the weakness of our economy. In 2011, the GDP of West Wales and the Valleys was 64% of the European average, lower than the Czech Republic, Slovenia and Slovakia. In contrast, London’s GDP was more than three times the European average.  

Because West Wales and the Valleys has a GDP of less than 75% of the EU average, it qualifies for additional funds to support its economic development. Since 2000, Wales has received over £4 billion from these “structural funds.” These funds have benefitted the long-term unemployed, the disabled, young people lacking in skills and older people who have recently been made redundant. Admittedly, not all of this has been used in the most beneficial (the redevelopment of Swansea bus station being a notable example). Nevertheless, EU projects have still yielded results. According to the Welsh Assembly, since 2007, these funds have created 12,000 enterprises and over 36,000 jobs. Over a quarter of a million people have gained qualifications while some 55,000 people have been helped into further learning. EU funds are gradually unlocking the vast potential of Wales’ struggling economy.

Of course, supporters of Brexit would point out that leaving the EU would leave the UK government with billions of pounds that could replace EU funds. In theory, that’s true. But considering the way the current government has slashed the budget of the Welsh Government, I really don’t see that happening.

If the UK choose to stay in the EU, then Wales would continue to see jobs and enterprises being created. Our access to the world’s largest training bloc gives multinational businesses an additional incentive to base their production in Wales. That is the future the EU offers Wales. And that’s why I’m proud to vote to be voting to stay in the EU.