Friday, 11 September 2015

Why I didn't vote for Jeremy Corbyn

I believe in high levels of public ownership, high taxes for the rich and I’m pretty liberal about immigration. I’m against Trident, the IMF and austerity. So, as the Labour Leadership election rattles towards its imminent conclusion, I’ve obviously voted Corbyn, right?

Actually, though my inner Bennite is turning in his temporary grave, I haven’t even given Jezza my second preference.

So what’s come over me? Have I finally, at the ripe old age of 21, given way to the right-winger within?

Far from it. I really appreciate what Corbyn has brought to this contest. At a time when I feared my party would bury its socialist past, Red Labour stands ready to take the helm.

The campaign against Corbyn has taken many forms. Much of it has been vitriolic and unfair. But some of it has been justified. Personally, I have doubts over whether such a divisive figure could ever provide Labour with one coherent message. While he may have the support of vast swathes of both the Party and the wider electorate, ultimately his effectiveness as leader depends on the loyalty of his own MPs. Without that, he risks leading an undisciplined Party that fails to deliver on its promises. Then he would let down the very people who to him to restore faith in politics.
Don’t get me wrong, I would love to see many of his policies implemented. But I worry that he won’t pick his battles, and will instead promise grand, unfeasible projects that will only cement the Left’s reputation as unrealistic.
But that’s not why my vote is going elsewhere.
 Even if he is elected as leader, Corbyn may not even survive long enough to write a manifesto, let alone fail to deliver it. But he would almost certainly lead Labour through the EU referendum, and the position he takes could well swing the vote one way or the other. Corbyn is the only candidate that has repeatedly failed to rule out campaigning for to leave the UK.

I understand why he hasn’t. He’s understandably concerned about Cameron’s attempts to whittle away EU workers’ rights. He is justifiably angry about the European Commission’s undemocratic attack on the Greek people. His opposition to the EU runs deeper, though, as his voting record makes abundantly clear.

Of course, I think the EU needs reform. It’s undemocratic and has too often favoured commercial interests over the rights of governments and citizens. But leaving the EU won’t change that. In fact, we may end up mimicking Norway’s “Fax democracy”, whereby EU regulations are adopted despite not having a voice in the European Parliament. But I think there’s a bigger problem with leaving the EU.
Corbyn’s issues with the EU seem to be fundamentally ideological. There’s nothing wrong with ideology. But it’s important to take a step back and consider why we have ideologies. Ultimately, I’m a socialist because I believe that it is the economic system that is best for the most vulnerable in society. It is that principle that must come first in any of my political beliefs. So while I worry about the neoliberal tendencies of the EU, I have to ask myself how withdrawal would affect the most vulnerable in society.

According to the Welsh European Funding office, EU funding has helped over 60,000 people back into work in Wales. While some EU money will have gone towards expensive vanity projects, much of it has gone to the most disadvantaged areas of Wales. It has funded hundreds of job creation schemes as well as research and development projects. In a small, poor country like Wales, the £500 million a year that we receive from the EU makes a massive difference. If we leave the EU, then we would most likely lose that money without compensation from the austerity-obsessed Conservative Government. Even a Labour Government would be hard pressed to plug the gap.

So I’m convinced that leaving the EU would hurt the most vulnerable in society. It would leave Britain out of the EU’s promising progress in the fight against climate change. If we leave the EU, then the very people that Corbyn wants to help will suffer.


Though I hate to say it, Corbyn is the wrong leader to guide us through the EU referendum. At any other time, I could overlook his beliefs about Europe. But not this time.