Monday, 11 May 2015

Why did the Conservatives win? (No it's not because the electorate are evil)

At 10pm on Thursday, just as the polls closed and the exit polls were announced, the post-match analysis began. Labour had lost Scotland- that was clear. Soon, as successive target remained stubbornly blue, it became obvious that Labour had lost England and Wales as well.

And then came the condemnation. Britain had become no more than “an aggregation of self-interest” proclaimed Reverend Giles Fraser in the Guardian. With less eloquence, thousands of statuses and tweets condemned the “selfish” and “narrow-minded” voters. According to them, when faced with the choice, the electorate had voted against compassion in favour of austerity. How could they be so callous, so ignorant, so self-centred?

Call me an optimist, but I can’t bring myself to believe this cynical version of events. Don’t get me wrong- I hate what the Conservatives have done over the last five years. I think they do stand up for the rich. And yes, of course, like many, I posted a status expressing my despair. And I have definitely generalised Conservative voters. (I’m sorry to say it’s often been intentional on my part.)

Though it may go against the left-wing inclinations of some Labour supporters, myself included, we’ve got to recognise that the majority of people voted Tory out of good intentions. No doubt, some people were motivated by selfishness. But the same could be said of any party. And we’ve got to remember that floating voters continue to play a decisive role in democracy. Did the Conservatives secure a majority with a swing of just 0.8% because 0.8% more people are now more selfish than they were 5 years ago? No, I don’t think so.

The Conservatives won because they had a clear and emotive argument. In essence, it was this: “Labour overspent. By “living beyond their means” they caused the recession. As a result, we’ve had to make difficult choices. It’s been tough but we’ve saved the economy. Vote Labour and they will ruin the economy once again”.
Whatever you think of the starting premise, you can’t deny it’s coherent. More than that, it’s emotive. Those who saw their wages cut during the recession know what it’s like to make difficult choices. When they earned less, they spent less. By applying this logic to the economy, the Conservatives have turned something complex into to something everyone can relate to.

If voters accept this line of reasoning, then all of Labour’s good intentions will come to nothing. If Labour caused the last recession, then they won’t be able to deliver the strong economy they need to carry out their promises. Zero hours contracts, lower tuition fees, affordable housing- each one is meaningless idealism if you believe that a Labour Government would drag us back to the chaos of 2009. The Conservatives have presented the electorate with a clear choice between austerity and the economic meltdown. With the best of intentions, they chose the lesser of two evils. And we can’t judge them for that. 

Yes, the logic of the Conservative argument “makes sense”. It’s coherent. It’s emotive.
But it’s based on a series of lie that shamelessly distort the truth. Labour didn’t overspend- in fact, between 1997 and 2003, on average, they kept the books balanced. It’s true that the deficit did rise in the years leading up to 2007. But only by 3% of GDP, which that was far from country-crippling levels. In fact, by 2007 Labour had achieved lower levels of borrowing than they had inherited from the Conservatives.

Of course, then the recession hit. But did Labour cause the global recession? No, it was only during the recession the deficit hit such high levels. Why? Rising unemployment was pushing up the welfare bill to rise just as tax revenues were falling.  The same would have happened to any government. Of course, Labour was forced to bail out the banks. But by doing so, they made sure that the savings of millions of people and thousands of businesses were safe. And so, by 2010, the economy was slowly growing again. So if spending wasn’t out of control, then how did Labour ruin the economy? The short answer is that they didn’t. Now of course I would say that (I’m a raving lefty). I’m also clearly not an economist. Just listen to theNobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman, who described the Conservative argument as  “delusional”. The Cambridge economist Ha Joon Chang calls it an “economic fairytale”. Sir Nicholas MacPherson, the non-partisan Permanent Secretary to the Treasury, is clear that the recession was caused by a “banking crisis pure and simple”.

 And of course there are so many flaws with comparing the public finances to a household. True, when households face financial difficulties, they make cutbacks. But unlike households, governments can increase their income. I don’t know about you, but there are no tax avoiding millionaires in my home. There are limits to how much we can tax and how much we can invest. The balance between cuts, investment and taxation is up for debate.

But one thing is clear- rather than ruining the economy, Labour saved it.

But you wouldn’t have guessed that from the way Labour spoke about it. For the last five years, the Party has allowed the Conservative’s deceitful narrative to dominate the public debate. Far from challenging it, they’ve apologised for it. So much of their election campaign was spent saying “sorry, we’ll do better next time”.

By the last TV debates, when Miliband finally did argue that Labour hadn’t caused the recession. But it was too little, too late. By then, the Conservatives’ argument had become so mainstream that Miliband seemed to be going against common sense. So the audience, and then the electorate, judged him to be economically incapable.

If Labour had fought the Conservatives’ narrative earlier, if their version of events had been challenged outside of the Guardian and the Independent, then maybe the Conservatives would have been seen as the Party with the ‘ludicrous’ argument.

In a democratic country, political parties and politicians shouldn’t just follow the public debate. They should inform it, lead it and even challenge it. Instead, Labour gave in and apologised for something they had never done.

No wonder the electorate judged them economically incompetent. Yes, democracy has failed us. But not because voters are selfish, callous or stupid. For the last 5 years, we have been presented with a series of lies by the Conservative media. The failure of democracy began when both Labour and the media left those pseudo-facts unchallenged.


If anything, it is democracy that has failed the voters, not vice versa.