Thursday, 30 July 2015

Calais Migrant Crisis: Barbarians at the Gates?

“Swarms.” That’s how David Cameron described the thousands of migrants at Calais. While he was swiftly condemned by Labour and human rights groups, some sections of the press have made his remarks seem positively welcoming. “Send in the Army,” bellows the Daily Mail with a characteristically mild-mannered and compassionate opinion piece that was mistakenly published instead of the news. “Send in the Gurkhas,” says the Telegraph in an article apparently ghostwritten by the East India Company at the height of Imperial expansion. The Sun, of course has its own take (well, Murdoch’s take), opting for a “headline” (“Softy Calais goes ballistic…Frenchies are atrocious”) that has all the coherency of a twelfth-century peasant on Facebook.

What is common to so much of the coverage is a chilling disregard for the humanity of these migrants. The Daily Mail talks of “asylum seekers being caught within 24 hours.” Never mind the fact that “asylum seeker” is the legal status for someone who is waiting for a decision on their application for asylum. Considering the number of migrants from Syria, Afghanistan and Libya who are trying to get into the country, it’s pretty obvious some of them will have a legitimate case. Not all of them, granted. As liberal as I am about immigration, I know we don’t have the resources to accommodate everyone who tries to get into the UK. But that doesn’t mean we can’t still treat them with respect. While I can understand the frustrations of those stuck at Calais, we’ve got to remember where the things that these people have been through to get here. Even those who may not be eligible for asylum have still gone to extremes to get where they are. They’ve suffered for it. That doesn’t excuse the behaviour of a minority who have been violent towards lorry drivers, but it should lead us to temper our response with maturity and compassion.

I know somebody who came into the UK in the back of a lorry. Before that, he had come to Europe in a people smugglers’ boat. Why? He was imprisoned in Iran for daring to renounce his Islamic faith. Rejected by his family and banned from following his new faith, he was unable to continue living in Iran. He was desperate. Since his asylum application was granted, rather than “living off welfare” he has worked tirelessly in low-paid jobs to support himself independently.

If that doesn’t convince you, just think of some of the other migrants trying to get into the UK through Calais. Over the last three months, the number of children seeking asylum and needing foster care after arriving in Dover has rocketed to 605. That’s more than twice as many as last year. Imagine it- children as young as twelve fleeing war-torn countries, being smuggled across Europe and then having to hide in the back of a lorry. All without a parent.

These are the people the papers have described as a threat. These are the people that the army would have to fight. But many of them are victims, whether they are eligible for asylum or not.

Yes, we have to deal with the queues at Calais. We’ve got to minimise disruption to holidaymakers and lorry drivers. And we’ll need to deport those who don’t qualify for asylum.


But none of that means we can’t treat people with dignity and respect.

No comments:

Post a Comment