Sunday, 19 April 2015

Is Britain full? Wrong question


“Ed Miliband, do you think Britain is full? Supposing we got to a figure of 70 million in 10 or 15 years, is that acceptable? 75 million? 80 million? 95 million? 100 million”

That’s the question that Jeremy Paxman put to Miliband in the recent leaders’ interviews. It’s a question the Labour leader refused to answer. Why should he? It’s a stupid question. Is Britain full?! What on earth does mean? There are less than 700 people per square mile in the UK. That doesn’t sound very full. Particularly when we remember that in Monoco, that figure is 50,000. Of course, Paxman wasn’t talking about space. He was talking about resources. But then again, “Do you think that Britain has the resources to cope with modest population growth in a country that has grown by 50 million in the last two centuries?” doesn’t have quite the same ring,.

So instead he made it seem like accepting a new immigrant into Britain means pushing someone else into the North Sea.

It’s the sort of question a twelfth-century peasant might ask when 10 newcomers walked into his village. After all, back then, this seemingly-overcrowded isle had a population of just 3.5 million then. Now that figure is 65 million.

“Is Britain full?” a medieval Paxman might have asked. “Supposing we got to a figure of 4 million in 10 or 15 years, is that acceptable? 6 million? 10 million? 20 million?”  

Now you may say that this comparison is a little extreme. Of course, population change over centuries is different to population change over decades. But it highlights the intrinsically subjective nature of Paxman’s question. To us, it might not seem like we have the capacity to cope with a growing population. But then the medieval peasant would have said the same. As might a Londoner before the onset of the Industrial revolution. Our own perceptions about whether Britain is “full” are frankly meaningless.

But surely population growth has been significantly higher in recent times? Not really. Between 1911 and 2011, the population of England and Wales grew by 27 million. To us, that may seem staggering. But it’s hardly historically unprecedented.  In fact, it’s barely an increase on what we saw in the hundred years before 1911, when population grew by 26 million. That’s even more remarkable when we consider the growth in relative terms. Between 1811 and 1911, Britain’s population more than tripled. That's what you call unprecedented. By contrast, our population hasn’t even doubled over the last century. And even that growth has been fairly stable.


Of course, the population growth during the Industrial Revolution did have a serious impact on living conditions. But even the most apocalyptic warnings over immigration don’t talk of anything like that. Britain is richer today. Both social protection and public services are stronger today.  We coped then and we are better able to cope today. And so history hasn’t repeated itself over the last century. Neither am I inclined to think it will do over the next.
Is Britain full? It’s more than the wrong question. In the context in the immigration debate, it’s a particularly odious thing to ask. Instead of addressing the issue, it exploits our fears, pitting “us” against “them”. Fundamentally, it’s a question that is designed to scaremonger and scapegoat.

Though the question claims to be about overpopulation, it clearly isn’t. Immigration isn’t the only cause of a growing population. It’s not even the biggest cause, not by a long shot. From what we’ve heard I the debates, we probably all know that net migration is running at 300,000 a year. But what we don’t hear so often is just how many people are born each year. In 2013, there were 810,000 births across the UK. You do hear it said sometimes that immigrants tend to have larger families, but there’s no way that this could be a significant factor in those 810,000 births. The fact is, people have babies. Even British people. They will carry on doing so.  As they have done throughout human history.

If politicians genuinely thought that overpopulation was a problem, manifesto pledges would include a one child policy and forced sterilisation.

So why do we insist on asking if Britain is too “full”? Why do we think that Britain can’t adapt to new levels of immigration?  Nobody question whether it can adapt to new births. Why? Because everyone knows that those children will go on to contribute economically and culturally to this country.  So do immigrants. In fact, they are on average net contributors. Of course, a country takes time to adapt to a larger population. Any movement of people has an impact on the labour market.  There are many challenges and so we need to make sure that immigration is fair and sustainable for everyone involved.  Issues like housing need attention for all our sakes.  Some controls on immigrations are necessary to make sure that all of us, immigrants included, can continue to contribute to this country and enjoy its benefits.  Exactly which controls we need is a different question. I’m not trying to weigh up the pros and cons of immigration here. What I am saying is that we won’t reach some level when Britain becomes ‘full’ and we have to start chucking immigrants into the English Channel. We need to be wary when politicians and the media give us that impression.


There is certainly nothing wrong with debating immigration. I think, in the past, staying silent on its challenges has done more harm than good. So it is completely right for us to look for answers to tough questions. But before we start pitting ourselves against each other, let’s make sure that the question that we ask are the right ones. 

No comments:

Post a Comment